Rating: 4/5 Stars
Holy shit.
This book
was pretty damn good!
After
finishing the fast-paced yet unoriginal, Legend, I wasn’t sure whether I wanted
to keep reading the series. I would like to finish it yes, but not because the
last book left me wanting to know more, in fact the first book ended on a “meh”
note for me since I couldn’t care less about what happened to Day’s brother (Ok
I know I sound like an asshole, and I am one, but the author spent more time
developing the insta-love romance between Day and June than focusing on the
characters other relationships.)
However, I
was pleasantly surprised by Prodigy. It still had its clichés, and the story
tried to push the Hunger Games vibes a little too hard sometimes, but in the
end it stood as a book unique in its concept; instead of trying to take down
the evil government, why not try to fix it?
In
dystopias, all we ever see are teenagers trying to take down the oppressing
government that doesn’t let them do stuff like love or shit like that (why is it always love??), but they never
really consider what it means to take down a government. What about the people
who will die in that war? What kind of new government do you implement, how do
you even know what to do (hey they are teenagers after all)? How can you be
sure that you are doing something good by destroying the existing regimen? How
do you know you are not making it worse? But in Young Adult, that’s hardly ever
considered. The authors just think “guns!” “kisses!” “boom! Boom! Boom!” and
that’s about it.
In Prodigy
we get to see two sides from June and Day’s perspectives and for once I was
grateful for the dual POV. Day belongs to the working class, he’s been
oppressed, used and abused; he wants to end the government because of how much
him and his people have suffered. But June, she was a prodigy! She had a good
life, a great education, and she was a pride to her nation: she wants for the
Republic to survive, but she also wants to make it better for everybody.
Both sides
presented great arguments for wanting the things that they did, but I again
found myself inclining towards June’s point of view; the republic needs to
change, not to be destroyed. I think Day was just so caught up with his hate
toward what they had done to his family that he was forgetting how many people
would die and suffer if the Republic actually did go down. June knew this, and
she wanted to make sure everybody was safe, she wanted to change the republic
so that everybody would have equal opportunities, AND EVEN THOUGH the Republic
had killed her ENTIRE FAMILY (unlike Day who still had his brother and Tess),
she still wasn’t after revenge, but after a better country for everybody.
However,
there were still some issues with the book, like how much it wanted to resemble
the Hunger Games. First when the rebels wanted to make Day the symbol of their
rebellion, I had to roll my eyes a little, especially with his whole “I never
wanted this or cared to change things, I’m just doing it for my little
brother.” Are you shitting me?? The Trials, although it didn’t feature kids
killing each other, it was still a copycat of the Arena and the games, how it
was used to keep the population under control and all.
Now,
there’s a twist at the end that I did not expect, but that it makes me want to
read the final book and see how it goes!
I recommend
this for people who are fans of dystopias and don’t mind a few hints to THG
here and there, but also to the people who tried the first book and weren’t
sure whether they’d like the series or not!
No comments:
Post a Comment